I do not want Starfield as a result of I’ve The Outer Worlds

Starfield will probably be one of many largest video games of 2023, however I’m not that excited to play it but.

Whereas  Starfield’s highlight on the Xbox & Bethesda Video games Showcase this yr highlighted some spectacular options, I couldn’t shake the sensation that I’d already gotten every part I’d need from a conventional sci-fi RPG like this from one other recreation: The Outer Worlds from Obsidian Leisure. Mockingly developed by one other Microsoft-owned studio, The Outer Worlds confirmed that bloating up a sci-fi recreation with hundreds of planets isn’t essential when a “much less is extra” mentality can nonetheless lead to an expertly designed sci-fi RPG. 

Though The Outer Worlds may not be as almost as grand as Starfield in scope, it nonetheless leaves an impression each time I revisit it. It’s a targeted, replayable, and hilarious journey with out a lot bloat, which is what I need from my RPGs. It does this whereas emulating Bethesda’s basic The Elder Scrolls and Fallout video games too, beating Starfield to the punch.

Starfield may impress me when it launches, however what I’ve seen of it hasn’t obtained me that desirous to play it once I’m so content material with replaying The Outer Worlds whereas avidly ready for its sequel.

Fewer worlds, extra enjoyable

From the second your escape pod by accident lands on a bounty hunter that’s supposed that can assist you, it’s clear that The Outer Worlds is a tongue-in-cheek, satirical tackle capitalism, colonization, and the sci-fi style as a complete. Whereas Bethesda Recreation Studios’ narratives have their fair proportion of humor, a lot of its writing tends to be extra severe and dryly written. We haven’t seen sufficient of Starfield’s dialogue or narrative to get a way of its thematic id but.

Starfield’s narrative may very well be extra playful than we’ve seen thus far, however the recreation’s large scope is what actually worries me. Throughout the Microsoft showcase, Todd Howard boasted that there are over 1,000 planets to discover. As a result of Starfield is so large, I fear that it dangers feeling unfocused. Will I get bored on planets that aren’t very handcrafted and don’t have as a lot to do? It’s the identical potential situation that infamously plagued No Man’s Sky at launch.

In the meantime, The Outer Worlds and its upcoming sequel are deliberately designed to keep away from these bloat points, based on former Obsidian Leisure Narrative Designer Nitai Poddar in a 2019 Recreation Informer interview. “There’s loads of worth in having an open-ended recreation that’s nonetheless structured round particular person discreet ranges,” he mentioned. “It additionally tends to be simpler to develop, and I’m at all times a fan of taking advantage of a price range that you’ve.”

The Outer Worlds’ builders didn’t have an enormous price range, and stored the sport small however very tightly designed consequently. You may not be capable to discover complete planets or fly between them, however you’ll positively keep in mind what you probably did on each single one you visited. This smaller scope allowed the studio to make the world extra reactive to every dialogue selection and participant choice.

Enjoying a combat-focused construct in The Outer Worlds provides you a completely completely different expertise than a dialogue-driven playthrough. You can even homicide or scorn everybody you meet in The Outer Worlds, and the sport accounts for it in tangible, narrative methods. This makes The Outer Worlds an amazing sci-fi roleplaying expertise, and I’m hopeful its sequel will probably be too. I’m not as hungry for a sci-fi RPG on such a probably problematic massive scale anymore when The Outer Worlds and its handcrafted worlds and narratives are so fulfilling moment-to-moment, similar to basic Bethesda video games. 

The place each video games will boldly go

So far as sci-fi experiences go, Starfield can stand out from The Outer Worlds with its fight, base-building and shipbuilding, and area fight. However relating to the core tenets of Bethesda’s finest RPGs — compelling characters, well-written narratives, and many reactive and choice-driven moments — The Outer Worlds beat Starfield to the punch with none further fats. I have already got the Bethesda-like sci-fi expertise I at all times needed.

Fortunately, this isn’t a contest between studios or an either-or situation for all Xbox administration and gamers. Each Starfield and The Outer Worlds can coexist as profitable franchises in Microsoft’s wider gaming lineup. Starfield has a number of function variations that can make it stick out extra to diehard Bethesda followers and people extra attention-grabbing in flying round in area or constructing a base on a planet. I’m joyful that Microsoft is keen to place out two comparable sci-fi RPGs as a result of it is aware of they’re each distinctive sufficient to face on their very own, even when I find yourself preferring one over the opposite.

Nonetheless, virtually each purple flag I see in Starfield is one thing that The Outer Worlds so expertly averted. I’ll definitely go into Starfield with an open thoughts when it launches, and I hope I’m stunned and completely benefit from the expertise. If it doesn’t totally grip me, I gained’t lose sleep over it; I’ll simply return and do one other playthrough of The Outer Worlds.

Starfield will launch for PC and Xbox Collection X/S throughout the first half of 2023. The Outer Worlds 2 has no launch date, however the authentic and its expansions can be found on PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One and Xbox Collection X through Xbox Recreation Cross, and Nintendo Change.

Editors’ Suggestions